Skip to main content

Dr. Stephen Greenfield: Catch Wrestling is a Distinct Wrestling Style

Dr. Greenfield with the successor of Billy Riley, Roy Wood

If I hear "it's just a ruleset" or "it's all grappling" - yes it is a form of grappling, as is Judo , BJJ, they all have their distinctive points, techniques, nuances, history and strategy. Yes CACC had a rulset (it is a little more complex than that), but it was not JUST a ruleset. There was and is an art, which was practiced in the Lancashire region that made its way around the world, was taken up by the populations there after the likes of Tom Connors spread it to America - it was passed on and developed by the likes of Farmer Burns, Frank Gotch, etc., in America, Carrol, Charnock, etc., in the UK. Despite the time apart, the art of CACC shown by Jon Strickland from Billy Wicks, and that shown by Roy Wood from Billy Riley are remarkably similar not only on a macro but micro level with individual points on technique being almost word for word the same.

When you read match accounts from early 1900's for example, and see the Japanese or the continental guys compete, or Cornish, or Westmoreland, Sumo, etc., they didn't call themselves catch wrestlers or Lancashire wrestlers just because they were competing under that ruleset, just as the likes of Joe Carroll didn't suddenly call himself a Jujutsu player because he took on Tani under the Japanese rules. They were called Jujutsu or Greco or Cornish wrestlers, whatever art it was they practiced - yes they took part in contests under different rulesets such as Catch, Greco, Cornish, Jujutsu etc., they still declared their 'base' art as their identifier - to say something is just a set of rules or say something not codified, etc., really doesn't seem to sit well with the overwhelming majority of historical evidence. 

Lancashire wrestling, Catch as Catch Can, was a distinct style of wrestling, as were others in the same way Judo was distinct, even Jujutsu with multiple ryu-ha with different philosophies and names for techniques was still identifiable as Jujutsu (although historically other terms such as Yawara, etc., were used). There were arts that contained varieties of movements, that taught in specific ways, with holds, ways of teaching, etc. When matches occurred they were fought under a set of rules or articles of agreement for a particular match (and it didn't vary as widely as is put out in the mainstream to support their points mostly around weight, falls, handicaps, etc., there is a remarkable similarity generally).

So to say all grappling arts are the same is to denigrate the history and characteristic of each.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Curran Jacobs Submits his Way to Gold at the 2017 Frank Gotch World Catch Tourney

Curran Jacobs of Michigan submitted accomplished wrestler and MMA veteran Travis Wiuff twice in one day to take first place in the 2017 Frank Gotch World Catch Wrestling Tournament in Humboldt, Iowa today. This year’s tournament featured the twelve toughest and bravest wrestlers in the world in an open weight division. Third place was won by Anthony Pacheck of Iowa, in a submission win over Christopher Morales of Los Angeles.
“That was the best catch wrestling match I have ever seen” said an enthusiastic Mike Chapman regarding the first match between Jacobs and Wiuff. “This was a brutal tournament,” said exhausted Curran Jacobs after winning gold, and a $500 cash prize.

Olympics Highlight Need for Catch As Catch Can Wrestling

How many points can you score in six minutes? That is how many Olympics wrestling matches are decided. Getting points for passivity and pushing your opponent out of the circle are not in the spirit of wrestling. If the goal of wrestling was to pin your opponent, then adding points and short time limits change the goal. A wrestler can win by out scoring the opponent. It seems like the rules of freestyle are designed to make sure that the wrestling event is over quickly. An example of this would be the aforementioned push out, or awarding a point if a wrestler cannot score after being put on the shot clock.

The tragedy of wrestling and grappling events is that wrestlers and fans are emotionally devastated when a wrestler loses by a small difference in points. Catch Wrestler, and former captain of the Michigan State wrestling team, Curran Jacobs stated in a recent interview for Takedown Wrestling that he always fell short of becoming an All American wrestler because of a slight point dif…

The Origin of the "Grovit"

We posted this image of American Catch Wrestling master, William Wicks doing a front face lock, or "Grovit." Many people had questions about the term, "Grovit."  Here is an explanation by Dr. Stephen Greenfield. 

"The original meaning was associated with a local word for an animal such as a sheep with a misshapen jaw (usually overshot). I believe it was applied to the name of a tool as a reference to the shape. As far as the Wigan Grovit, I would suspect it was in reference to the appearance of someone who had it applied to them."

Dr. Greenfield is a physician, wrestler, and historian who works with the Snake Pit Wigan